Aerial view of a house with a dark asphalt shingle roof

When a skylight leaks, start where it meets the roof. Skylights are among the most common sources of water getting into a home, and VELUX, a skylight maker, names the installation as today's main cause of leaks: a hole cut to the wrong size, a skylight that's the wrong size, or the wrong flashing for the unit. Work on the roof around it can cause a leak too. And sometimes the water isn't a leak at all, just condensation running off the inside of the glass. Work out which one you have before anyone starts patching.

Leak or condensation

Rule condensation out first, because it can look exactly like a leak. Warm indoor air holds more moisture than cold air, and when it touches cold glass, some of that moisture turns to water. It happens mainly in winter, when the difference between a heated house and the air outside is greatest. Over a kitchen or a bathroom, where there's more moisture in the air, condensation on a skylight can drip onto the floor or stain the skylight well in cold weather.

So notice when it happens. Water that shows up after rain points to a leak. Drops all over the inside of the glass on a cold day, rain or no rain, point to condensation. What proves a leak is a fresh stain or a puddle after rain, or after the roof and skylight are tested with a hose.

Condensation gets fixed inside the house, by cutting the moisture in the air. VELUX's advice is to run the kitchen and bathroom exhaust fans more often in winter, and to keep blinds and shades open so warm air can reach the glass. New flashing won't stop it.

How a skylight is sealed to the roof

On a shingle roof, the joint around a skylight is sealed with layers of metal, each lapped so water runs over it and onto the shingles below. A metal apron runs along the bottom edge and overlaps the shingles below it. Up each side, L-shaped step flashing is woven in between the shingle courses. Across the top, the head flashing slips under the shingles above, and those shingles stop short of the skylight, leaving a strip of bare metal that clears leaves and speeds the water off.

A peel-and-stick membrane under the flashing adds a backup layer. Even with careful flashing, a storm from just the right direction can drive water behind it. The residential code that UpCodes publishes for Pennsylvania requires flashing around roof openings, and a skylight is a roof opening.

Why the flashing fails

Installation is the usual reason. If the flashing doesn't suit the skylight, or the skylight doesn't fit the opening, it's going to leak. Metal flashing that was put in wrong can also flex over and over until it cracks.

Roof work is the other thing to know about. The scraping and hammering of taking shingles off and putting them back can jostle a skylight in its frame and break the flashing, VELUX says. If the leak started soon after other work on the roof, tell us when you call.

Then there's sealant. Sealant at the top corners suggests someone has already treated that spot as a leak point, and a bare nail head at a corner is a sign of a poor installation. Caulk has its place, but caulk is not a substitute for properly lapped flashing. Our posts on leaks around a chimney and around a plumbing vent pipe say the same.

Hail is different. It can damage the glass enough to let water through, and that's the skylight itself, not the roof around it.

Signs the leak is at the skylight

You can narrow it down without going on the roof.

  • Look around the skylight from inside. The signs are peeling paint and water stains on the framing around the opening.
  • Find the highest stain. The leak will be above the highest point around the skylight where you can find water stains or damage. Water can travel under the roofing first, so the wet spot isn't always right under the opening.
  • Check from the attic after rain, if you can get there safely. Flashings are the most vulnerable points on a roof, so look closely at the boards around the skylight for dark or wet patches.
  • Look from the ground with binoculars for metal that's lifted or bent around the skylight, leaves piled against its top edge, and smears of tar or sealant along the joint.

If the stain is nowhere near the skylight, our guide to hidden roof leaks will help you trace it. If you're not sure the water is coming from the roof at all, read whether to call a roofer or a plumber first.

Leave the roof itself to a roofer. Only roofing professionals should climb onto a roof.

How a skylight leak gets fixed

A water test tells the flashing from the skylight. In dry weather, water is run down the roof onto the uphill end of the skylight and around it, while someone watches inside. Then it's run onto the glass itself. A leak that shows only when water runs down the roof points to the flashing. A leak around the glass frame points to a problem with the glass seal.

From there, the repair matches what failed.

Planning a new roof? Ask what happens at the skylight. Re-roofing can disturb its flashing, so find out whether the estimate puts new flashing there or reuses the old.

Get the leak traced before it's sealed

When you call us about a skylight leak in Allentown or anywhere in the Lehigh Valley, we work back from the stain to where the water is getting in before we fix anything. If the problem is in the roof around the skylight, meaning the flashing, the shingles or the deck under them, we'll put the price of the roof repair in writing. That estimate is free. If you'd like the whole roof and attic looked over, our roof inspection is a separate, paid service that ends with a written report.

Seeing a stain around a skylight after rain? Call (484) 553-0213 or request an estimate.

Get a No Cost Roof Estimate